Difference between revisions of "Ghyll talk:Meldersen"
PhineasCrank (talk | contribs) m (I pushed this envelope myself, back in the old days, when I was funny) |
Morbus Iff (talk | contribs) (Ayup, thanks, explanation, yadda yadda.) |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
| − | I observe that rule #3 states: "Scholars shall neither cite themselves, nor write phantoms they were the first to cite." | + | I observe that rule #3 states: "Scholars shall neither cite themselves, nor write phantoms they were the first to cite." I mention this because your entry on [[Luminous manuscript]] cites Melderson. --[[User:DrAckroyd|Dr. H. L. Ackroyd]] 16:05, 20 Dec 2004 |
| − | I | + | Well, if I recall correctly, as long as it's not one of your citations, it can be done. In other words, your one old and two new links/entries/citations can NOT refer back to your own work, but after that, it's up for grabs. (And, I'm sure I'll be corrected if I'm wrong.) -- [[User:PhineasCrank|Doctor Phineas Crank]] 16:11, 20 Dec 2004 (EST) |
| − | + | ''Who watches the watchers?'' You're both right. Yes, rule #3 was violated unknowingly by myself (as I both ''originally'' phantomed [[Meldersen]], and then cited it in my ''required per-turn citations''), but this should now be fixed ([[Meldersen]] was swapped out with a newly created phantom, the [[Iganefta Recorder]]). Thanks for catching this. --[[User:Morbus Iff|Morbus Iff]] 00:12, 21 Dec 2004 (EST) | |
Revision as of 00:12, 21 December 2004
I observe that rule #3 states: "Scholars shall neither cite themselves, nor write phantoms they were the first to cite." I mention this because your entry on Luminous manuscript cites Melderson. --Dr. H. L. Ackroyd 16:05, 20 Dec 2004
Well, if I recall correctly, as long as it's not one of your citations, it can be done. In other words, your one old and two new links/entries/citations can NOT refer back to your own work, but after that, it's up for grabs. (And, I'm sure I'll be corrected if I'm wrong.) -- Doctor Phineas Crank 16:11, 20 Dec 2004 (EST)
Who watches the watchers? You're both right. Yes, rule #3 was violated unknowingly by myself (as I both originally phantomed Meldersen, and then cited it in my required per-turn citations), but this should now be fixed (Meldersen was swapped out with a newly created phantom, the Iganefta Recorder). Thanks for catching this. --Morbus Iff 00:12, 21 Dec 2004 (EST)
